At a glance
The Redemption of Sarah Cain
Christian Amish Fiction
The Redemption of Sarah Cain
320 pages · First published 2000
Successful Portland real estate broker Sarah Cain has built a comfortable life far removed from the Amish community her estranged sister Ivy embraced years earlier. But when Ivy dies, Sarah is stunned to discover that she has been named guardian of her sister's five children in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania. Determined to settle the matter without sacrificing her career or independence, Sarah finds herself at odds with the grieving children, particularly sixteen-year-old Lydia, who promised their mother she would keep the family together. As Sarah struggles with her responsibilities and the painful memories of her relationship with Ivy, the simplicity, faith, and unexpected kindness of Amish life begin to challenge everything she thought she wanted. A moving story of forgiveness, family, and spiritual renewal, this heartfelt novel is ideal for readers who enjoy Amish fiction, reluctant guardians, found families, and journeys toward hope and reconciliation.
Paired for this story
Jump to the pours ↓Spiced Maple Latte + Amaretto Sour
Choose your bookseller
Find the Book
Print retailers offer a search when an exact edition is unavailable. Kindle links open a specific edition. Audiobook links may open an edition or a search.
Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, Book Bartender earns from qualifying purchases. Bookshop.org links also earn us a commission on qualifying purchases. Your price is not affected. Read the full affiliate disclosure.
No surprises at chapter twelve
Content notes
Death of a sister and orphaned children, with significant grief; References to a child's death and a fatal farm accident; Family estrangement and emotionally strained relationships; Mild romantic content, including kissing
Alcohol-Free Pour
Spiced Maple Latte
Rich espresso softened by warm milk, maple, and cinnamon reflects Sarah's transition from a fast-paced Portland career to the quieter comforts of Pennsylvania Amish country.
What you'll need
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.How to mix it
- Stir the sweetener and spices into hot espresso, then add steamed milk.
- Garnish: Light dusting of cinnamon, optional.
- Glassware: Mug.
Shop glassware & tools
We earn a commission from qualifying purchases through these Amazon links, at no extra cost to you.
Mug ↗Cocktail Pour · 21+
Amaretto Sour
For adults of legal drinking age. Please drink responsibly.
An Amaretto Sour's balance of tart lemon and sweet almond mirrors Sarah's journey from resentment and grief toward forgiveness, faith, and the unexpected sweetness of family.
What you'll need
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.Alcohol-shopping links are not shown on children's or young-adult book pages.
How to mix it
- Shake amaretto and lemon juice with ice, adding simple syrup only if desired. Strain into a glass over fresh ice.
- Garnish: Lemon wheel and cocktail cherry.
- Glassware: Rocks glass.
Shop glassware & tools
We earn a commission from qualifying purchases through these Amazon links, at no extra cost to you.
Rocks glass ↗Set up the bar cart
Shop the Barware
Find the glasses and tools for your next pour.