At a glance
Plain Jane's Secret Admirer
Christian contemporary romance
Plain Jane's Secret Admirer
Jane has never liked the childhood nickname that makes her feel forgettable, and her quiet nature does little to help when it comes to her longtime feelings for Samuel Mast. Samuel is hardly more confident, leaving both of them trapped behind shyness, assumptions, and things they have not said aloud. The arrival of an anonymous admirer adds another layer of uncertainty as Jane tries to decide whether romance is finally moving toward her or simply becoming more confusing. This gentle Amish romance centers on two reserved people, self-worth, and the courage required to risk an honest answer.
Paired for this story
Jump to the pours ↓Portuguese Rose Lemonade + Sloe Gin Fizz
Choose your bookseller
Find the Book
Print retailers offer a search when an exact edition is unavailable. Kindle links open a specific edition. Audiobook links may open an edition or a search.
Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, Book Bartender earns from qualifying purchases. Bookshop.org links also earn us a commission on qualifying purchases. Your price is not affected. Read the full affiliate disclosure.
No surprises at chapter twelve
Content notes
Longstanding hurt from a cruel childhood nickname; secret-admirer deception and anonymous gifts; romantic rivalry/second admirer; shyness and emotional insecurity; Amish/Christian faith and sweet romance.
Alcohol-Free Pour
Portuguese Rose Lemonade
A bright, refreshing sip suits romantic anticipation and a little escapism.
What you'll need
- 1 1/2 oz fresh lemon juice ↗
- 1/2 oz rose syrup ↗
- 5 oz cold water
- 4 raspberries ↗
- Ice
How to mix it
- Muddle raspberries lightly with rose syrup. Add lemon juice, cold water, and ice; stir well.
- Garnish: Raspberries and lemon wheel.
- Glassware: Highball glass.
Shop glassware & tools
We earn a commission from qualifying purchases through these Amazon links, at no extra cost to you.
Highball glass ↗Muddler ↗Cocktail Pour · 21+
Sloe Gin Fizz
For adults of legal drinking age. Please drink responsibly.
A crisp botanical pour suits romantic anticipation and a little escapism.
What you'll need
- 2 oz sloe gin
- 0.75 oz fresh lemon juice ↗
- 0.25 oz simple syrup, adjusted to taste ↗
- 2–3 oz club soda ↗
- Ice
Shop the spirits 21+Search Total Wine for Gin · 21+ ↗
How to mix it
- Shake sloe gin, lemon juice, and simple syrup with ice. Strain into a highball glass over fresh ice, top with club soda, and stir gently.
- Garnish: Lemon wheel.
- Glassware: Highball glass.
Shop glassware & tools
We earn a commission from qualifying purchases through these Amazon links, at no extra cost to you.
Highball glass ↗Set up the bar cart
Shop the Barware
Find the glasses and tools for your next pour.